Showing posts with label opinions. Show all posts
Showing posts with label opinions. Show all posts

Saturday, 28 September 2019

On 'Dangerous' Places and Who Defines Them

Hello there, readers. I am writing this blog post from a new location today: Paris, that famous city of love, light, and disappointingly few berets. Those of you who know me in real life (or perhaps follow me on certain social media accounts) will probably be aware that I recently moved here from my old university town in Wales. It was quite a dramatic decision and so far it's working out semi-well, but that's not what I'm writing this post about. Having never been to Paris, or even France for that matter, I looked to other people for advice on the city before coming here. Specifically, which areas were good places to live and which ones I should avoid at all costs. As I was receiving this guidance, a friend said something that struck me as rather odd. When referring to a particular area in the north of the city (which shall remain nameless, because I'm not here to debate the merits of that neighborhood today), he stated that while it was a poor area, it wasn't dangerous. However, he then went on to add that it was not a safe place for a woman to be out alone at night. Do you see the contradiction here?

The word 'dangerous', according to the University of Oxford's Lexico dictionary, means:
  • 'Able or likely to cause harm or injury', or
  • 'Likely to cause problems or to have adverse consequences.'
Antonyms for the word include 'harmless' and, notably, 'safe'. This area in Paris was described as 'not safe' for lone women at night. Therefore we can assume that this place is the opposite of safe: dangerous. Right? Not exactly. 

The issue here is something of a doublethink problem. The place in question can be both dangerous and safe at the same time, because it is not dangerous and safe in the same situations for the same type of people. It is generally deemed safe, because the people for whom it is seen as dangerous are viewed as exceptions to the rule of safety. Yes, this place is safe - except for women, especially women on their own and particularly women who are out at night. There is an element of danger here that is being acknowledged, but that danger is seen as minor enough that it can be left out of the overall verdict of this place being 'safe'.

Some people, my friend most likely included, might not see a contradiction here. After all, no place is 100% safe for everyone all the time. Still, it got me thinking: how do we define a place or a situation as dangerous? Moreover, who gets to define them as such? Is a place safe if it's only dangerous at night? Is it safe if it's only dangerous for women? 

The answer probably depends on who you ask. In the past, I've been shocked at my male friends' ignorance of the dangers women experience. I once had a guy friend at uni tell me about a time he thought he was being followed home at night, which scared him so much he held his keys between his fingers in case he was attacked. When I told him that I did that every time I walked home in the dark, mysterious follower or not, he didn't believe me. The idea that our quiet little university town could appear dangerous even without the presence of an obvious threat (e.g. someone following you) was unimaginable for him. Likewise, when I've said that I find Saudi Arabia in some ways a safer place than the UK because I experience less street harassment in the former, women have understood while the men I spoke to were incredulous, insisting that there was no way anything like that happened more in the UK, a country they saw as not nearly as dangerous when compared with Saudi. 

This ignorance is not limited purely to men though. A little while ago, a report was making the rounds on social media that said the majority of same-sex couples were afraid to hold hands in public, for fear of harassment or worse. This was hardly a revelation for me or my then-girlfriend, who would always do a quick check of our surroundings before considering any public display of affection or would simply avoid it altogether in some situations, such as when walking past groups of drunk people at night. Although I appreciated that awareness was being raised, it did kind of surprise me that the report was news to anyone. I was even more surprised when I realised many of the straight people I knew were shocked to find out that people like me and my girlfriend were ever afraid to hold hands anywhere in the UK. Even though I knew straight people didn't experience it, I thought this threat of homophobic harassment was common knowledge. Once again, people failed to recognise danger when it didn't affect them directly.

This is not to say that I am in any way exempt from these sorts of blind spots. As a white person, I am often ignorant of dangers which primarily affect people of colour. Although I don't trust the police anymore, I was still able to last well into my teens before I began to stop viewing the British police as the benevolent authority figures I'd been taught they were as a child. For many people of colour, this distrust can be instilled in them since childhood. I was able to maintain that ignorance because for white people, the police do not present so much of a threat as they do for people of colour. My whiteness had allowed me to develop a kind of privileged naivety, just as maleness or straightness had done for my friends.

We all have our blind spots, no matter which minorities you might belong to, and my point in writing this post is not to condemn people who were just trying to give me helpful advice about an area in Paris. In fact, just acknowledging that an area is dangerous for women at night is more than I get from some men, who neglect to consider that an area which is safe for them might not be nearly so safe for women. The flat I currently live in overlooks a street, and sometimes when I look out at night and see men walking alone while there is not a single woman in sight, I wonder if they know how lucky they are. That is what I am asking for in writing this post: a consideration of how you experience danger, an acknowledgement of how privileged you might be if a place seems safe to you, and a reminder that just because you deem an area harmless, that may not be the case for everyone else. 

Monday, 5 August 2019

Is Speaking Up Always Worth It?

A couple of weeks ago, I had a conversation that I've been thinking about ever since. At the time, I was bemoaning what I saw as the hypocrisy of straight and cisgender allies who will happily accept awards for "supporting the LGBT+ community" in public but then will fail to call out friends and family who say bigoted things in front of them. My parents responded by saying that, to be fair to those supposed allies, speaking out in such situations isn't always worth it.

This statement has been playing on repeat in my mind for the last month or so, and for a while I couldn't figure out why it bothered me. While I understand the idea of picking your battles and know that it would be impossible to call out every slightly problematic statement we encounter in life, something about the idea of shrugging off a prejudiced comment with the defence that "it's just not worth it" troubled me. After giving it a lot of thought, I think I've figured out why.

First of all, let's consider how we decide what makes taking a stand in a situation "worth it". In any interpersonal situation, I would argue that most people (subconsciously or otherwise) weigh up the costs and benefits of a statement before we make it. Most people don't go around saying whatever is on their mind at any given moment, at least in part because to do so would be socially damaging. A cost-benefits calculation applies to any interaction, even apparently innocuous ones like deciding whether or not to tell everyone the terrible pun that just came into your head (benefits = they may think it's hilarious; cost = they may think it's awful and never wish to associate with you again), but in this case I want to consider specifically the situation wherein a person you are with makes an offensive comment and you have to decide whether or not to contest it. The potential costs of the situation will vary, but will likely take into account the possibility of the following: making a scene, losing standing among social group, being seen as a killjoy, angering the person who made the comment, and so on. In more extreme situations, you might have to consider the likelihood that your physical safety could be endangered or you could even be arrested, but those are less likely and not what I'm really addressing here. Either way, it seems that you have a lot to lose if you speak out in a public situation. What then are the possible benefits of it? What do you stand to gain here? There is your personal dignity, of course, the sense that you have stood up for your moral principles and done "the right thing". Then there is the chance that you could change the mind of the person who made the comment. Perhaps you could sow a seed of doubt in their intolerant mind that will one day blossom into acceptance and understanding - but is that really worth the risk?

Here's where I believe the problem lies. If you see the only tangible benefit of speaking out as possibly changing the mind of the bigot in question, of course it's not going to seem worth it. I feel that this, along with the feeling that you're abiding by your personal code of honour, are usually the only benefits taken into account when people weigh up whether or not to speak up in the face of ignorance. My issue, then, is that there are other benefits which are not being considered.

There's more to speaking out against intolerance than the possibility of changing the offending person's mind, and to reduce it to that is to disregard the other important effect of taking a stand: reducing harm. If you are in a group, it's always worth considering that even if nobody else contests whatever offensive thing is being said, that doesn't mean none of them were affected by it. I can't count the number of times I have been in a group situation when someone has said something homophobic that I found deeply hurtful, but which I found myself unable to respond to either because I was still in the closet or was afraid of being attacked further if I said anything. Every one of those times, if just one person had spoken out and said that whatever homophobic thing was mentioned wasn't on, I would have felt relieved and infinitely safer in that situation. Yet almost every time it happened, nobody said anything. Remember this: no matter how uncomfortable you feel contesting a bigoted comment, it is nothing compared to how people of the marginalised identity in question will feel. If you want to be a true ally, your job at times like that is to speak up for the people who can't speak for themselves.

So that's my defence of speaking up in group scenarios, but what about in one-to-one conversations? What if it's just you and one person, and you know that there's no chance of anybody overhearing? In that case, the benefit of questioning what they've said is that it might make them a bit slower to repeat similar statements in future. As a queer person, I don't care if most people are homophobic in their thoughts - what I do care about is that they keep them to themselves. Even if you think telling your friend to shut up won't change their mind, it will still indicate to them that their bigotry is not acceptable. Very often, it is this belief that their views are not socially acceptable that stops people from participating in obvious bigotry, rather than a true sense that it is wrong.

I say all that to say this: keeping silent is just as much of a choice as speaking up, even if it is the easier option. I can't speak for other marginalised identities, but I will say that if you are a man or a straight person, one of the greatest things you can do for me as an ally is to question sexism and homophobia when you encounter it. The sad fact is that your objection will likely carry more weight than mine would, and you are less likely to be put in danger by speaking up. The next time you are confronted with the choice to speak up or remain silent, I hope that you will consider first and foremost the impact that your choice will have on the victims of intolerance, rather than the potential to convince people with intolerant views.

PS: Thank you to my parents for providing the inspiration for this post!

Sunday, 30 June 2019

Scrumptious, Delectable, and Other Words I Can't Stand

I don't have strong feelings about the word 'moist'. The internet would lead you to believe that the majority of people are disgusted by it, yet I've personally never found it that bad. It's definitely not the nicest-sounding word in the world, but neither is it the worst. The thing I associate it with the most is cakes, and I certainly don't see it as having a sexual connotation, despite what Urban Dictionary may tell you.

I always thought people's responses to 'moist' (I'll stop using it now, for those of you who are bothered by it) were a little over-the-top. Who would get so disgusted by a simple word, without any context? That was what I thought until quite recently, when I realised that there are several words that cause me to have a similar reaction of total, irrational repulsion. All of these words seem to sit in the same vague, broad category, but these are two of the worst: scrumptious and delectable.

Of these two, scrumptious is very obviously the worst. I hate hearing either of them out loud, but saying 'scrumptious' makes me feel like my teeth are going to jump out of my mouth in protest. 'Delectable' feels like it has the potential to be pleasant to say, since it has lots of clear consonant sounds and doesn't all run into one mushy noise at the sides of your mouth like 'scrumptious' does - but still, the meaning ruins it for me. That's the biggest problem with these words: their associations. Like I said before, I think these two words fit into a broader category which is in itself a kind of niche within adjectives-associated-with-food. To give you some idea of what I mean, here are a few other words that I would also place in the same group (and which also cause me to experience varying degrees of revulsion):
  • flavoursome
  • scrummy
  • toothsome
  • delish
  • delicious (in certain contexts)
  • yummy
  • succulent
Do you see the connection? All of these words are normally (but not always) used to describe food, and they all cause me to experience discomfort ranging from a mild cringe (succulent) to wanting to temporarily remove my ears and store them in a secure location where they can no longer be exposed to such horrors (scrummy). So they're all terrible, food-related words, but there's also some other aspect to them which I can't quite pinpoint.

I asked a few people if they felt the same disgust I did at these words, and although most people found my plight amusing rather than relatable, one of my sisters did provide some insight. She said that the words (specifically scrumptious and delectable) seemed 'pretentious' and 'try-hard posh'. Funnily enough, for me these words automatically conjure up an image of a comically upper-class person, perhaps the sort to be a grande dame or her effete son, saying something like "Oh, Jeeves, these canapés are simply delectable!" 

So there seems to be a common association of these words with pretentiousness, but I don't think that completely explains why they bother me so much. Another problem with them is that they seem, for lack of a better word, over-pronounced. I can barely imagine someone saying them without extra emphasis on the stressed syllable: delectable, yummy, succulent, delish, scrumptious, and so on. This has got to account for at least half of my disgust, because when I force myself to pronounce them with fairly neutral emphasis they don't bother me so much. Perhaps I'm unusually sensitive to this sort of thing, since I find it equally cringeworthy when people over-emphasise the last consonant in a word, as in tick (ticKK) or pot (poTT), with the extra exhalation of air at the end. That said, it oddly doesn't bother me at all when the consonant is turned into an entire syllable, as in tick-u or pot-u, which I've known some of my English students to do.

Still, there is one more element of these words that I can't stand. For some reason, they frequently have a sort of suggestive connotation, which makes them sound almost lascivious when said aloud. It doesn't help that some of them can explicitly apply to attractive people (usually women) as well as food. According to Lexico:
  • 'Scrumptious' can mean '(of a person) very attractive'. It uses the example, 'He was the most scrumptious thing on two legs', which coincidentally makes me want to hurl myself off a cliff.
  • 'Delectable' can be a humorous word for 'extremely attractive'
  • 'Yummy' can mean 'highly attractive and desirable' - a definition familiar to anyone who's heard the nausea-inducing phrase 'yummy mummy'
  • 'Scrummy' is only listed as meaning 'delicious', but it then lists the example sentence, 'If it isn't scrummy Sean Bean playing photography lecturer Paul'
  • 'Delicious' has a secondary meaning in 'delightful', but then includes the example sentence, ‘But then Nicole arrives looking simply delicious, and her voice is tolerable enough.’
To be fair, some of the words I mentioned before, like flavoursome and succulent, don't seem to have any alternatively suggestive meanings besides referring to things like plants. Then again, I don't think it's a coincidence that the words with unambiguously food-related meanings are less repulsive to me. There's also the example of the word 'delicious', which I have absolutely no issue with when used in a food context but can't stand when used to refer to anything else. The latter immediately makes me think of a posh, creepy old man who enjoys the sound of his own voice far too much and has a habit of making inappropriate comments about young women in the vicinity  - but then perhaps I've just ended up with an unfortunate association, and my hatred of these words is a total overreaction. 

I'd be very interested to know if anybody else finds these words even half as bad as I do, or if there are any other words or phrases that bother you for unknown reasons. I think the psychology behind revulsion and abjection and all that is fascinating, and I'd love to discuss it further - just don't ask me to say any of these cursed words out loud. 

Monday, 17 June 2019

In Defence of Stop Trump: Why the Cardiff Protest Matters

When I set up this blog the other day, I wasn't really intending to write about political issues. That said, there's one particular subject that's been on my mind for the last few weeks, and I'd like to get my thoughts out here while they're still semi-relevant.

A few weeks ago, on Saturday, the 1st of June, a friend and I made the journey from our little town in West Wales to Cardiff. Our main goal was to attend the Stop Trump protest we'd heard was happening that day, but in true activist spirit we decided to book a hotel and make a weekend of it. Our Megabus didn't get into town until around midday, so by the time we had dropped off our luggage and made our way to City Hall Lawn, the march had already begun.

From what I can gather, the protest started with some talks on the lawn and then progressed into the march through central Cardiff, at which point my friend and I joined in. The march was accompanied by placards and megaphone chants, with a couple of police officers shepherding us along. The procession eventually looped back around to City Hall Lawn, where we stopped and listened to a few short speeches by members of various activist groups in Cardiff. Once those had ended, the crowd began to disperse and myself and my friend decided to head off.

I am giving this description here to illustrate that this was, all in all, a fairly standard protest. There was nothing particularly controversial or shocking about it, no milkshaking (sadly) and no significant police intervention. I had never expected the event to be huge or incredibly controversial, even before attending, which is why it came as a surprise to me to hear so many people respond negatively to it before I had even gone. When I mentioned to people that I was attending the protest, most of them were unexpectedly critical of it. This wouldn't come as a surprise if the people I spoke to were Trump supporters, but I knew for a fact that most of them ranged from being indifferent to outright despising him. So why would they be so disparaging of a protest that was against the very man they disliked? The explanations they gave were varied, but most were based in either a misunderstanding of the goals of the protest or a lack of belief in its effectiveness. In the list below, I am going to paraphrase some of the main reasons people had for objecting to the Stop Trump protest and why, in my opinion, the protest was still worthwhile.

Reason #1: "You do realise you won't actually stop him coming, right?"

You do realise that a great way to make a statement come across as painfully condescending is to start it with "you do realise", right? But seriously, I think that this comment stems from a misunderstanding of what "Stop Trump" means: it doesn't just mean "stop Trump coming to the UK on this particular visit", it also means "stop Trump's continued assault on the most vulnerable in society and the general far-right movement of which he is a part". Most of the people attending the protests were no doubt well aware that Trump would end up coming to the UK whether we protested or not (as evidenced by the fact that the London protest was scheduled for after his arrival). The aim of the protest wasn't to literally make Trump's plane turn around and go back to America mid-way across the Atlantic (although that would have been nice), but to create a show of solidarity that aims towards bringing a stop to the harm which Trump is causing overall.

Reason #2: "I don't want to give that man any of my time or energy."

On one hand, I respect the disdain for Trump evident in this comment. On the other hand, I feel like this once again comes back to a misunderstanding of the protest's aims. Stop Trump isn't purely about Trump, as counter-intuitive as that may sound. One of the things that struck me at the march was the diversity of the attendees, not just in terms of things like age and gender (although the march was very diverse in that respect as well), but also in terms of the causes they represented. There were people marching who were representing LGBT+ rights, anti-racism, Palestine, no borders, anti-austerity, women's rights, and so on. It was a great testament to the variety of people who have been brought together under the shared banner of opposing Trump  - an aspect of the protest which Stop Trump seem fully aware of. On the Facebook page for the event, the details section contains the following statement:
"When we say "Stop Trump" we are saying stop discrimination, stop war, stop austerity, stop climate chaos, justice for Palestine, respect LGBT+ communities, refugees welcome, celebrate diversity, and resist the suppression of democracy and dissent."
That's it, in a nutshell. The protest was fundamentally about showing solidarity with the people who Trump has hurt and has the potential to hurt the most, not about Trump himself.

Reason #3: "Trump just feeds off negative attention like this."

This comment makes me think of Trump as some kind of malevolent, blob-like entity that literally feeds off human emotions, growing stronger every time you so much as say his name - kind of like a reverse Tinkerbell. Mystical, emotion-eating ideas aside, I do think that this "don't feed the trolls" principle of not giving attention to deliberately controversial people does have some validity, but only in certain contexts. If, for example, you get some internet person making vaguely inflammatory statements in the comments section of a YouTube video, you might be perfectly justified in simply ignoring them. Their comments could be irritating and clearly an attempt at starting a fight, so not responding could in fact be the best response you could make. The same thing goes for creators (such as YouTubers - starting to see a theme here) who make unpleasant, potentially-harmful content that doesn't yet have a huge following. In that case, bringing attention to such a creator could very well help to build their audience and eventually end up spreading the ideas you initially wanted to critique. However, this approach does not work for Trump. For one thing, unless you have been living in an underground bunker with no Wi-Fi for the last ten years - and if you have, I envy you - then you will almost definitely know who Trump is. He is also already in a position of power, meaning that he can and will continue to cause harm, whether or not we "feed" him with negative attention. More than negativity, Trump feeds off silence. Ignoring Trump won't make him or his impact go away, so it is important that we speak up and express solidarity with the people he is hurting as often as we can. To be silent is to be complicit, and protesting is one way to break that silence.

Reason #4: "It's not going to make any difference anyway."

Ah, the big one. It's this lack of belief that I think keeps so many people out of activism, or in fact trying to make any change to the society we live in, and that is not a criticism of these people so much as it is of the system which makes them feel that way. I think people perhaps felt this especially strongly about the Cardiff protest, because it wasn't as large as the later protest in London and didn't receive as much media coverage (although it did get mentioned on Wales Online). I've already mentioned why the protest mattered in principle, so let me go over some of the more tangible effects I think this protest has had. For one, it showed solidarity with the marginalised groups Trump and his ilk repeatedly attack. I know I have mentioned this point before, but it's worth stressing. As a queer woman, whether or not someone supports Trump is an indirect litmus test for whether or not they support LGBT+ rights and, by extension, my rights. It's hard to articulate what a nice feeling it was to be at the protest and to be surrounded by people that were willing to stand up in defence of people like me, people who were not staying silent in the face of violence against LGBT+ people, among other marginalised groups. Of course solidarity is just a start, but seeing it displayed so obviously at this protest made me feel very hopeful, which is not something I feel often these days. Another point that some argue is that protests in the UK won't make a difference to events in America, but these protests are also a statement for our government that we are against their support of Trump, and their willingness not only to keep quiet while he enables outrageous human rights abuses but also to then roll out the red carpet for him when he visits the UK. It is my hope that protests like this will make politicians think more carefully about how they approach Trump in the future, even if it is now too late for Theresa May to do so. Finally, even if you think that none of this matters when it happens on the scale of the Cardiff protest, you should know that the event also raised money to transport people to the bigger protest which happened in London shortly afterwards. Most of these points that I've made apply to the London protest as well, if not more so.

If, before reading this post, you were unconvinced by the value of the Stop Trump protest in Cardiff, I hope that you are now at least a little bit more receptive to my reasons for attending, even if you haven't entirely come around to it. At the end of the day, most of us have so little political power in our society that we are left with only two main ways to create change: voting and protesting. Sometimes, voting just isn't enough. I felt that this was one of those times.